Modern Military Portal Fantasy Novels and Kumotawa Confluence
Modern military portal fantasy is a subgenre of speculative fiction where contemporary armed forces—soldiers, vehicles, tactics, and technology—are transported through a portal or dimensional rift into a fantastical world filled with magic, mythical creatures, or pre‑industrial societies. The core appeal comes from the clash between modern military power and the unfamiliar environment of a fantasy realm, often exploring themes like technological superiority, cultural misunderstanding, ethical dilemmas, and the limits of force when confronted with magic or radically different civilizations. It blends the gritty realism of modern warfare with the wonder and unpredictability of high fantasy, creating stories that hinge on strategic adaptation, world‑building contrasts, and the consequences of two very different worlds colliding.
This subgenre serves as the ultimate "What If?" for history and military buffs. However, the most successful stories are those that recognize that while a bullet can kill a wizard, it cannot easily kill the social and political structures that the wizard represents. Themes that are often present include:
- Tactical Friction: The narrative focuses on the technical "crunch" of combat. It asks how a Kevlar vest fares against a magical arrow, assault rifles versus knights, or how a .50 machinegun handles a target like a dragon.
- The Logistical Clock: A central tension is the depleting supply chain. Without a modern industrial base, a soldier is only as effective as their last magazine. This leads to a race against time to manufacture ammo, refine fuel, or create replacement parts in a world with no factories.
- Technology "Uplift": Because they are cut off from Earth, the modern force often must jumpstart an Industrial Revolution. They teach local populations how to build steam engines, produce penicillin, and create rifled muskets just to maintain their survival.
- Moral & Cultural Shock: These stories often examine the friction of modern Rules of Engagement (ROE) and modern values when applied to feudal, often brutal, fantasy empires.
There are also three popular variations in this subgenre based on the size of the military unit that is sent to another world.
- The Squad: A small unit (Rangers, Marines) must survive behind enemy lines. Examples: Forgotten Ruin, Doomfarers of Coromonde
- The Nation/Base: An entire island, ship, or nation is transported, requiring the story to deal with the logistical clock and technology uplift issues. Examples: Island in the Sea of Time, Destroyermen
- The Stable Gate: A permanent portal allows for logistics, trade, and politics between Earth and the other world. Examples: Gate, Manifest Fantasy.
I enjoy reading portal fantasy and when I wrote my novel "Kumotawa Confluence" it combined tropes from urban / contemporary fantasy with military portal fantasy and "girls with guns" anime. I aimed for a more character driven and "realistic depiction" in the story with some rich world-building that included Japanese myth, magic, and travel between worlds.
I'll talk more about my novel at the end, but first, I want to give a rough chronology of some famous military portal fantasy works. Hopefully it will introduce something new to anyone looking for additional reads in this genre.
Title: The Doomfarers of Coromonde
Author: Brian Daley
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy | Year: 1977
Plot Summary: While fighting in the Vietnam War, a squad of US soldiers and their armored personnel carrier (APC) are suddenly plucked from the jungle by a wizard's spell. They are brought to the high-fantasy world of Coromonde to help a prince overthrow a dark sorcerer and slay a dragon. The narrative explores how M60 and .50 machine guns, 40mm grenades, and tactics hold up against ancient sorcery and mythical monsters.
Significance: This is one of the earliest "Modern Military vs. Fantasy" works and quite enjoyable.
Title: Janissaries
Author: Jerry Pournelle
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Science Fiction / Fantasy | Year: 1979
Plot Summary: A group of American mercenaries, led by Captain Rick Galloway, are about to be slaughtered during a botched mission in Africa. They are rescued by aliens and deposited on the planet Tran, a world populated by humans abducted from various eras of Earth's history (Romans, Vikings, etc.). The mercenaries must use their superior knowledge and limited modern gear to survive and eventually dominate the medieval landscape.
Significance: Written by a pioneer of hard military science fiction, Janissaries focuses heavily on the uplift of primitive societies. It is often criticized for its Cold War-era cynicism and the perceived moral superiority of the Western protagonists over backward cultures.
Title: The Lost Regiment: Rally Cry
Author: William R. Forstchen
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Fantasy | Year: 1990
Plot Summary: The 35th Maine Volunteer Infantry, a Union regiment during the American Civil War, is transported by a mysterious fog to a world where humans are hunted for food by the Tugars—ten-foot-tall nomadic aliens. The soldiers must industrialize a medieval human civilization from scratch, building steam engines and rifled muskets to defend humanity from a massive horde.
Significance: The series is a masterclass in the logistics of war, showing the extreme difficulty of manufacturing 19th-century technology without a modern supply base.
Title: Island in the Sea of Time
Author: S.M. Stirling
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy / Alternate History | Year: 1998
Plot Summary: A mysterious atmospheric phenomenon (The Event) transports the entire island of Nantucket, along with the US Coast Guard sailing ship Eagle, back to 1250 BC. The modern Americans must figure out how to survive in the Bronze Age, interacting with legendary civilizations like the Mycenaean Greeks and the Egyptians, while a renegade Coast Guard officer tries to set himself up as a god-king.
Significance: The acronym for this book, ISOT, became the term for the "entire location transported" trope. It is praised for its immense world-building but occasionally criticized for its graphic violence and dark depictions of ancient warfare.
Title: Weapons of Choice (Axis of Time trilogy)
Author: John Birmingham
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Science Fiction / Fantasy | Year: 2004
Plot Summary: In the year 2021, a multinational UN humanitarian task force (led by the massive carrier USS Hillary Clinton) is conducting an experiment with a "wormhole" drive. A catastrophic accident transports the entire fleet back to 1942, appearing directly in the middle of the US fleet steaming toward the Battle of Midway. The "Transition" is violent; modern ships accidentally collide with and destroy WWII vessels. The trilogy explores the total collapse of the historical timeline as the "21st-centurians" deal with the cultural shock of 1940s racism and sexism, while the Axis and Allied powers race to reverse-engineer future technology.
Significance: The series is highly significant for its brutal realism regarding cultural friction. Unlike other savior stories, Birmingham highlights the horror 1940s Americans feel toward the integrated, socially progressive future military.
Title: Destroyermen: Into the Storm
Author: Taylor Anderson
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy (Historical) | Year: 2008
Plot Summary: During the early days of WWII, the aging destroyers USS Walker and USS Mahan are fleeing from a superior Japanese force in the Pacific. They pass through a freak squall and emerge on an alternate Earth where evolution took a different path. They find themselves in the middle of a war between the Lemurians (peaceful, lemur-like humanoids) and the Grik (predatory, raptor-like lizards).
Significance: This is one of the longest-running series in the genre (15 books)! It is lauded for its unique alternate evolution world-building and the technical accuracy of WWII naval warfare.
Title: Gate: Thus the JSDF Fought There!
Author: Takumi Yanai
Classification: Light Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy | Year: 2010
Plot Summary: A portal appears in Tokyo, unleashing a fantasy army. After the Japanese Self-Defense Force (JSDF) repels the invaders, they enter the portal to the Special Region. The series follows a Ranger who is also an otaku as he leads a reconnaissance team to make contact with locals, fight fire-dragons, and navigate the politics of an Empire that resembles ancient Rome.
Significance: Gate is arguably the most famous modern example of the genre. It is controversial for its perceived Japanese nationalism and for depicting the JSDF as morally flawless while portraying other world governments (US, China, Russia) as villainous or incompetent.
Title: No Man’s World: Black Hand
Author: Pat Kelleher
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy (Historical) | Year: 2010
Plot Summary: In 1916, during the height of the Battle of the Somme, a several-mile-wide chunk of the French battlefield—including the 13th Battalion of the Pennine Fusiliers—is suddenly ripped from Earth and transported to a bizarre, alien planet. The British Tommies, still entrenched in their mud-clogged trenches, find themselves surrounded by a hostile alien wilderness and strange, magical phenomena. They must maintain military discipline and survive against both alien "monsters" and a group of German soldiers who were transported along with them.
Significance: This series is significant for its historical ISOT approach, focusing on the specific psychological trauma of WWI soldiers. It is praised for its atmospheric blending of Trench Horror and Science Fantasy. Unlike stories with modern tech, the bolt-action rifles and limited tanks of 1916 make the fight against monsters much more desperate and balanced.
Title: Forgotten Ruin
Author: Nick Cole & Jason Anspach
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy | Year: 2021
Plot Summary: A group of US Army Rangers are transported ten thousand years into a future where Earth has become a high-fantasy nightmare. The Rangers must use their training to survive against orcs, dragons, and sorcerers in a world where magic has replaced technology for everyone except them.
Significance: This series revitalized the western military fantasy scene with an hardcore action and Tolkien vibe. It is highly praised for its authentic military culture and slang, though its intense focus on military jargon can be overwhelming for non-veteran readers. This series and these authors have quite a large following.
Title: Ice and Monsters
Author: Peter Nealen
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy | Year: 2022
Plot Summary: A squad of Recon Marines on a training mission in Norway is swept away by a mysterious fog. They arrive in a brutal, frozen world filled with monsters from Norse mythology and dark sorcery. With no support and limited supplies, the Marines must use small-unit tactics to fight a war they never expected.
Significance: Written by a Marine veteran, this work is noted for its "small unit" focus. It avoids the all-powerful military trope by putting the squad in constant, desperate danger where every magazine counts.
Title: Manifest Fantasy
Author: DrDoritosMD
Classification: Web Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy | Year: 2022
Plot Summary: Following the discovery of a portal in the United States, the US military initiates a First Contact mission with the world of Gaera. The story follows Alpha Team as they conduct reconnaissance and diplomatic missions, eventually leading to full-scale military engagements when a hostile empire threatens the peace.
Significance: This is a modern web-serial success story. It is significant for attempting a more balanced US Superpower perspective compared to Gate, though it still leans heavily into the military dominance fantasy that defines the genre.
Significant Japanese High Fantasy Novels With English Translations
Urban Fantasy Novels, Anime, Games Set In Japan
Cats and Coffee and Books Means It's Japanese Cozy Fiction or Fantasy
Magical Girls and Tactical Military Anime and Manga Development
Modern Military Portal Fantasy Novels and Kumotawa Confluence
More About Kumotawa Confluence
Thanks for reading to the end and seeing this blurb about my contemporary fantasy novel set in Japan. It contains a fusion of Japanese folklore, military action, and characters both ordinary and heroic.
Kumotawa Confluence plunges you into a world where ancient myth collides with the modern world. Yuriko, an ex–special forces operator turned small-town convenience store manager, investigates eerie disappearances on Mount Kumotawa. After meeting a mysterious cat, she uncovers a hidden realm of yokai and escalating danger.
Check it out to support an independent author! Fun summary below.
Title: Kumotawa Confluence
Author: Peter Lok
Classification: Novel | Genre: Military Modern Fantasy / Urban Fantasy | Year: 2022
Plot Summary: An ancient shrine stands as the final barrier against a darkness older than empires. A former special forces operator, a mysterious cat, her stalwart companions and students become the first line of defence for Japan and the world. The conflict escalates and more military forces are deployed into the fray.
Significance: It is blend of genres. There is a portal, with action happening on both sides of the portal. It has cats / convenience stores / coffee / idyllic settings that are common to Japanese urban fantasy. It has individual and special forces action with monsters and otherworldly menaces. There is mystery that you would find in X-Files, intense action found in 13 Hours or Blackhawk Down, yet it has magic in the form of Japanese imperial sorcerers and the Sword Princess. "Girls with guns" tropes from anime are also represented via the Gun Girls Auxilliary.
Comments
Post a Comment